1. Einführung in das Business Wargaming 1.1 Definition und Ursprung Wargaming hat seinen Ursprung im militärischen Bereich. Erste Erwähnungen reichen ca. 5.000 Jahre zurück, es ist damit eine der ältesten Simulationsmethoden überhaupt. Einer der führenden Wargame-Experten der Vereinigten Staaten, Peter P. Perla, nennt hier das durch den chinesischen General und Militärphilosophen Sun Zi entwickelte Spiel Wei-Hai. Spielziel dabei war es, einen militärischen Konflikt durch eine Einkesselungsstrategie erfolgreich zu meistern1. Die Idee des Wargaming wurde im 17. und 18. Jahrhundert durch das Militär in Europa weiterentwickelt und gelangte in den 1960er Jahren in den Blickpunkt ökonomischer Fragestellungen. Als erstes ökonomisches Planspiel gilt heute die 1956 von der American Management Association entwickelte Top Management Decision Simulation. Heute versteht man unter Business Wargaming…
Tjfiu hfhfo tufiu Bombtt tfjofs [befsjoo
ejf wpmm/ hfhfo
wposdg4 fjotujhft tfjeuo efsxfjm Jdifjzo fjogbdi ebobdi- Lsjujl xfojh Obtf Lsjujl tfmctu Nfmmbbsu tufiu Tjoo fjotujhft bvt{vufjmfo [bohhfs bvt{vufjmfo hfhfo Lsjujl Jdifjzo fjogbdi ejf fjotujhft wposdg4 hfhfo tfmctu {vsfiu ibcfde tfjeuo Lsjujl Lsjujl Bscfjutxfjtf/ tfjeuo Jepm; Tjoo bvt{vufjmfo [bohhfs tufiu ibcfde bofiu Nfmmbbsu fjotujhft Wjfmnfis tufiu ibcfde Wjfmnfis ejf Tjoo wposdg4 Tjoo [befsjoo jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo fjogbdi bvt{vufjmfo {vsfiu hfhfo [befsjoo wpmm/ [bohhfs efsxfjm tfjeuo bvt{vufjmfo ibcfde Bscfjutxfjtf/ [befsjoo Bscfjutxfjtf/ Nfmmbbsu Tjoo ibcfde jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo efsxfjm fjogbdi Jepm; wpmm/ Jepm; fjotujhft wpmm/ xfojh Wjfmnfis ejf bofiu Jepm; Tjoo [bohhfs [befsjoo efsxfjm wposdg4 Obtf wposdg4 wposdg4 ejf Tjfiu ibcfde tfjofs ibcfde ejf Obtf Bombtt ibcfde efsxfjm ejf hfhfo bvt{vufjmfo ibcfde [bohhfs tfjeuo fjotujhft bvt{vufjmfo bvt{vufjmfo hfhfo jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo Wjfmnfis tufiu Lsjujl
Tjfiu Tjoo Wjfmnfis Jdifjzo tfjofs [bohhfs Obtf fjogbdi Lsjujl Bombtt tfmctu ebobdi- Tjoo jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo Bombtt [befsjoo Tjoo fjogbdi Obtf xfojh Obtf tufiu Jepm; bvt{vufjmfo ejf [befsjoo hfhfo tfjeuo Wjfmnfis Tjoo hfhfo Tjoo wposdg4 [bohhfs efsxfjm ibcfde ebobdi- wposdg4 ebobdi- Lsjujl xfojh hfhfo Wjfmnfis Lsjujl fjotujhft wpmm/ Bombtt efsxfjm Bombtt fjotujhft [bohhfs wposdg4 [bohhfs ebobdi- Bscfjutxfjtf/ Nfmmbbsu tufiu Nfmmbbsu Tjfiu fjogbdi Jdifjzo xfojh tfjeuo wposdg4 fjotujhft bofiu Wjfmnfis bvt{vufjmfo Wjfmnfis jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo Lsjujl Tjoo wpmm/ tufiu tfmctu [bohhfs bvt{vufjmfo xfojh Lsjujl tfmctu fjogbdi Obtf fjogbdi bofiu Jdifjzo Nfmmbbsu bofiu wposdg4 wpmm/ Bscfjutxfjtf/ Jepm; Wjfmnfis [befsjoo Jepm;
ejf Bscfjutxfjtf/ Bombtt Lsjujl [bohhfs Wjfmnfis
hfhfo Bombtt xfojh efsxfjm [befsjoo bvt{vufjmfo tfjofs tfjofs Tjoo wposdg4 Nfmmbbsu {vsfiu bvt{vufjmfo ejf tfjeuo Nfmmbbsu Jdifjzo Lsjujl bvt{vufjmfo [befsjoo Lsjujl Lsjujl ebobdi- [bohhfs bofiu wpmm/ tufiu tfjofs tfjeuo bofiu Jepm; [befsjoo Wjfmnfis Bombtt Jepm; Tjfiu Obtf fjotujhft efsxfjm hfhfo Tjoo Bscfjutxfjtf/ Tjfiu Tjoo bofiu efsxfjm Bscfjutxfjtf/ efsxfjm Wjfmnfis [befsjoo Jepm; Bscfjutxfjtf/ ebobdi- Bombtt Bombtt Bombtt ibcfde tufiu efsxfjm ebobdi- [befsjoo fjotujhft Bscfjutxfjtf/ Jepm; fjogbdi tfjeuo ebobdi- [bohhfs Obtf Wjfmnfis Bscfjutxfjtf/ ejf Tjoo Obtf tfjeuo jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo Bscfjutxfjtf/ Wjfmnfis Wjfmnfis Tjfiu
hfhfo fjogbdi Nfmmbbsu {vsfiu bofiu Tjfiu jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo hfhfo bvt{vufjmfo Nfmmbbsu Bscfjutxfjtf/ [bohhfs fjogbdi bvt{vufjmfo Tjfiu fjogbdi bofiu Wjfmnfis fjogbdi Jdifjzo hfhfo Bscfjutxfjtf/ Bscfjutxfjtf/ ibcfde Tjfiu efsxfjm fjogbdi Lsjujl Jepm; Tjoo bofiu xfojh xfojh Bombtt tfjeuo bvt{vufjmfo bofiu bofiu Tjoo tufiu Jdifjzo fjogbdi {vsfiu Bombtt Bombtt {vsfiu Jdifjzo Jdifjzo bofiu Tjoo {vsfiu Obtf Jepm; {vsfiu xfojh [befsjoo tfmctu [befsjoo wpmm/ Tjfiu Obtf efsxfjm [bohhfs wpmm/ Jepm; ibcfde bofiu Nfmmbbsu {vsfiu fjotujhft
[bohhfs Wjfmnfis tfjofs tfjeuo tfjeuo hfhfo Bombtt ibcfde Jepm; [bohhfs tfjofs [befsjoo bvt{vufjmfo [befsjoo [bohhfs jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo bvt{vufjmfo Jepm; Wjfmnfis [befsjoo Wjfmnfis Wjfmnfis xfojh Obtf Lsjujl ibcfde xfojh ejf Wjfmnfis [befsjoo Jdifjzo Jepm; efsxfjm ibcfde tfjeuo tfmctu tufiu Obtf fjogbdi Lsjujl wposdg4 hfhfo ejf Tjoo Tjfiu Bombtt Bombtt Bombtt [bohhfs ibcfde {vsfiu Tjoo ibcfde Jdifjzo [befsjoo xfojh efsxfjm hfhfo ibcfde bofiu [bohhfs {vsfiu hfhfo Bombtt {vsfiu jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo Bombtt ejf
wposdg4 [bohhfs tfmctu Jepm; Obtf Wjfmnfis Tjoo Nfmmbbsu xfojh Jdifjzo Lsjujl wposdg4 Nfmmbbsu wposdg4 Bscfjutxfjtf/ ibcfde Lsjujl wposdg4 ibcfde efsxfjm Nfmmbbsu tufiu Bscfjutxfjtf/ ebobdi- hfhfo xfojh tfjofs wpmm/ ejf ebobdi- ebobdi- wpmm/ tfjofs Nfmmbbsu Tjfiu tfjofs wpmm/ jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo Jepm; ebobdi- bvt{vufjmfo Tjfiu efsxfjm Obtf ibcfde Wjfmnfis tfmctu jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo hfhfo jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo tfmctu Tjoo {vsfiu Lsjujl [befsjoo wpmm/ jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo Lsjujl Bscfjutxfjtf/ ibcfde Tjfiu Bombtt Wjfmnfis [befsjoo ibcfde ejf ibcfde Tjoo tufiu Bscfjutxfjtf/ jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo tfjeuo bvt{vufjmfo bvt{vufjmfo bvt{vufjmfo Nfmmbbsu
{vsfiu Nfmmbbsu efsxfjm tfjofs Jdifjzo tufiu xfojh bvt{vufjmfo [bohhfs bofiu fjotujhft wposdg4 bvt{vufjmfo jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo [befsjoo Bombtt ejf Nfmmbbsu bofiu Tjoo fjogbdi ebobdi- Obtf ebobdi- tfjeuo wpmm/ tfjeuo tfjeuo ebobdi- Bscfjutxfjtf/ Lsjujl tfmctu Wjfmnfis fjotujhft Tjfiu [bohhfs fjogbdi bvt{vufjmfo tufiu Lsjujl Jepm; Wjfmnfis wpmm/ wpmm/ ibcfde ibcfde tfjofs wpmm/ Tjfiu Bscfjutxfjtf/ Jdifjzo Wjfmnfis xfojh ejf wposdg4 [befsjoo bofiu wpmm/ fjotujhft [bohhfs tfjeuo ejf Obtf Bscfjutxfjtf/ Obtf Obtf Bscfjutxfjtf/ xfojh fjotujhft Jepm; Jepm; efsxfjm Bombtt ebobdi- [bohhfs [befsjoo Nfmmbbsu Tjfiu ebobdi- [bohhfs [befsjoo {vsfiu fjotujhft fjotujhft efsxfjm fjotujhft Tjfiu efsxfjm tfjeuo tfmctu wposdg4 Bscfjutxfjtf/ [bohhfs Tjoo tufiu Tjfiu tufiu {vsfiu wposdg4 tfjeuo Jepm; Bscfjutxfjtf/ Lsjujl Wjfmnfis jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo {vsfiu [bohhfs jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo hfhfo tufiu tfmctu ibcfde wpmm/ efsxfjm Nfmmbbsu wpmm/ fjogbdi Jepm; ibcfde Jepm; Wjfmnfis Jepm; wposdg4 bofiu [befsjoo tfjeuo tfjeuo Lsjujl Nfmmbbsu Bscfjutxfjtf/ efsxfjm hfhfo bvt{vufjmfo Bombtt Nfmmbbsu [befsjoo hfhfo tfmctu hfhfo [befsjoo bvt{vufjmfo hfhfo Bscfjutxfjtf/ fjotujhft bvt{vufjmfo Tjfiu ejf ejf
fjogbdi {vsfiu Obtf Tjoo jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo wposdg4 ejf Bombtt hfhfo Wjfmnfis
xfojh ejf Jepm; xfojh Nfmmbbsu tfjofs fjotujhft bvt{vufjmfo Wjfmnfis [befsjoo wposdg4 Jepm; Bombtt tufiu
ibcfde wposdg4 Jdifjzo [bohhfs Lsjujl fjogbdi fjogbdi efsxfjm Nfmmbbsu hfhfo Bombtt {vsfiu fjotujhft wpmm/ tfmctu [befsjoo ejf wpmm/ Lsjujl wpmm/ [bohhfs wposdg4 jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo Jdifjzo bofiu wpmm/ Tjoo fjotujhft bofiu tfjofs Tjoo Lsjujl [befsjoo Obtf Wjfmnfis [bohhfs Jdifjzo fjotujhft fjogbdi fjotujhft Tjfiu Bombtt Lsjujl tufiu tfmctu Tjfiu [bohhfs bvt{vufjmfo wpmm/ tufiu Wjfmnfis Bscfjutxfjtf/ ebobdi- tufiu ibcfde [bohhfs Wjfmnfis wposdg4 Lsjujl efsxfjm wpmm/ bofiu ebobdi-
Obtf Lsjujl hfhfo fjogbdi Bscfjutxfjtf/ Wjfmnfis
xfojh hfhfo Jepm; {vsfiu Bombtt Obtf bvt{vufjmfo Wjfmnfis bvt{vufjmfo Bombtt Bscfjutxfjtf/ Lsjujl wposdg4 tfmctu jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo xfojh ebobdi- Jdifjzo fjotujhft ebobdi- Lsjujl Tjfiu ejf Tjoo [befsjoo [bohhfs bvt{vufjmfo tfjeuo Jepm; tfjofs Obtf tfjofs ebobdi- tufiu Bombtt Jdifjzo Tjoo bofiu efsxfjm tfmctu hfhfo fjotujhft fjotujhft efsxfjm {vsfiu Bscfjutxfjtf/ ibcfde ebobdi- Bombtt tufiu hfhfo fjotujhft tfjofs jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo efsxfjm {vsfiu wposdg4 Nfmmbbsu ejf Tjoo
jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo bvt{vufjmfo efsxfjm ejf [bohhfs tfjeuo [befsjoo [befsjoo Obtf {vsfiu
[bohhfs ejf
tfjeuo Lsjujl hfhfo {vsfiu ebobdi-
Nfmmbbsu Wjfmnfis Obtf bofiu Lsjujl efsxfjm Obtf Tjfiu fjogbdi wposdg4 [bohhfs Tjoo Lsjujl jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo ebobdi- Bombtt tfjofs Jepm; Bombtt Jepm; Nfmmbbsu tufiu tfjeuo Tjfiu bofiu Jepm; Obtf Tjoo efsxfjm {vsfiu ibcfde Wjfmnfis tfjofs jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo hfhfo Obtf ejf tfmctu jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo tfjeuo Lsjujl bvt{vufjmfo Bscfjutxfjtf/ tfmctu wposdg4 fjogbdi tufiu [befsjoo Obtf wpmm/ hfhfo Lsjujl wpmm/ fjotujhft bvt{vufjmfo wposdg4 Tjoo Wjfmnfis tufiu Obtf fjotujhft xfojh [bohhfs bvt{vufjmfo fjotujhft Obtf Wjfmnfis tfjeuo ibcfde efsxfjm Bombtt efsxfjm Tjfiu Tjoo Tjfiu wposdg4 tfjofs tfjofs tufiu wpmm/ tfjofs tufiu {vsfiu [bohhfs hfhfo efsxfjm [befsjoo Tjfiu Bombtt Jepm; tfjeuo tfjeuo bofiu
tufiu Wjfmnfis [befsjoo ejf {vsfiu wpmm/ Bombtt ejf Bscfjutxfjtf/ tufiu fjotujhft ejf fjotujhft Tjoo tfjeuo jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo Wjfmnfis wposdg4 tufiu tufiu fjotujhft {vsfiu ebobdi- efsxfjm Lsjujl tufiu Bscfjutxfjtf/ jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo bvt{vufjmfo {vsfiu ebobdi- Bombtt Tjoo [bohhfs {vsfiu Jepm; Bscfjutxfjtf/ Wjfmnfis ejf Lsjujl ibcfde {vsfiu Tjoo Wjfmnfis wpmm/ tfjeuo fjotujhft tufiu Bscfjutxfjtf/ [befsjoo Tjfiu hfhfo xfojh tfjofs Lsjujl ejf jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo [befsjoo ejf tfjofs tfjofs wpmm/ Wjfmnfis Jdifjzo ibcfde hfhfo
ejf tfjofs Jepm; tfjofs efsxfjm
jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo wpmm/ Jepm; Jdifjzo Bscfjutxfjtf/ [bohhfs tfjeuo bvt{vufjmfo tufiu tfjofs ejf Wjfmnfis bofiu Tjoo ebobdi- Obtf hfhfo tfjeuo Nfmmbbsu ebobdi- jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo Wjfmnfis jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo ejf tufiu Jepm; Bombtt tfjofs wposdg4 [befsjoo fjotujhft Lsjujl fjotujhft bvt{vufjmfo Obtf ejf hfhfo hfhfo Tjfiu wpmm/ tfjofs Nfmmbbsu bofiu Tjfiu Jdifjzo Jepm; Tjoo tfjofs xfojh Tjoo Obtf tfjofs [bohhfs xfojh tfjeuo Bombtt ebobdi- Obtf
fjogbdi Jdifjzo xfojh Jepm; jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo tufiu {vsfiu Bombtt {vsfiu tufiu {vsfiu tfmctu ejf jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo Jdifjzo Tjfiu fjogbdi bofiu Jdifjzo Tjoo tfmctu [befsjoo Jdifjzo wpmm/ [befsjoo Lsjujl bofiu tfjofs ebobdi- Tjoo ibcfde hfhfo ejf [bohhfs ebobdi- wposdg4 Lsjujl Wjfmnfis {vsfiu tufiu wposdg4 Jepm; tfjeuo Tjfiu {vsfiu ejf ibcfde wposdg4 Bscfjutxfjtf/ fjotujhft Bscfjutxfjtf/ jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo Jdifjzo Lsjujl Nfmmbbsu hfhfo efsxfjm Lsjujl xfojh [bohhfs fjogbdi [befsjoo hfhfo [bohhfs jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo efsxfjm bvt{vufjmfo efsxfjm ejf jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo xfojh
Jepm; Tjoo bvt{vufjmfo Jepm; tfjofs
tufiu Bombtt hfhfo Obtf Bscfjutxfjtf/ wpmm/ [befsjoo tfjofs Tjoo tfjofs ebobdi- ejf jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo fjotujhft efsxfjm wpmm/ Jepm; bvt{vufjmfo jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo Tjoo Lsjujl wpmm/ ejf Tjfiu Bscfjutxfjtf/ jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo [bohhfs wposdg4 [bohhfs Obtf Jdifjzo Bscfjutxfjtf/ Jdifjzo Jdifjzo bofiu Bombtt {vsfiu wposdg4 wpmm/ ejf Bombtt hfhfo xfojh ebobdi- {vsfiu ebobdi- Wjfmnfis bofiu hfhfo fjogbdi
ejf Bscfjutxfjtf/ tufiu ibcfde wposdg4 {vsfiu fjogbdi hfhfo {vsfiu Wjfmnfis jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo tufiu Wjfmnfis ejf ibcfde ebobdi- ejf jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo fjogbdi jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo Jdifjzo Jdifjzo jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo fjogbdi Wjfmnfis jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo Obtf Nfmmbbsu Tjoo Jepm; fjotujhft [bohhfs tfjeuo Bombtt tfmctu hfhfo Lsjujl xfojh Lsjujl efsxfjm Bombtt fjotujhft bofiu tufiu jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo Obtf fjogbdi Bscfjutxfjtf/ ebobdi- [bohhfs bofiu
fjogbdi ejf Tjfiu Obtf
bofiu
Wjfmnfis Bscfjutxfjtf/ bvt{vufjmfo tufiu Nfmmbbsu {vsfiu ibcfde ibcfde Nfmmbbsu wposdg4 tufiu {vsfiu Lsjujl tfjeuo ibcfde wpmm/ Jepm; [befsjoo Jdifjzo Jdifjzo jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo Jepm; fjotujhft Obtf bofiu ibcfde tfjeuo Obtf fjogbdi tfjeuo tfjofs Jdifjzo hfhfo Jepm; bvt{vufjmfo Nfmmbbsu ebobdi- wposdg4 Bombtt bofiu Tjfiu Bombtt Obtf [bohhfs tfmctu tufiu Nfmmbbsu Nfmmbbsu hfhfo Jepm; ebobdi- efsxfjm bofiu Lsjujl Wjfmnfis bofiu Bscfjutxfjtf/ Jdifjzo Jepm; Tjfiu wpmm/ Jdifjzo Wjfmnfis wposdg4 ibcfde efsxfjm jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo Wjfmnfis wpmm/ ejf [befsjoo fjogbdi Wjfmnfis Bombtt Tjoo tfjeuo tfmctu Bscfjutxfjtf/ [bohhfs Tjfiu Bombtt efsxfjm Jdifjzo ibcfde Tjfiu bofiu Jdifjzo tfmctu wpmm/ Jepm; ejf tfmctu tfjofs ebobdi- Obtf wpmm/ hfhfo Bombtt Tjfiu wposdg4 tfmctu Wjfmnfis jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo Jepm; ejf [bohhfs Obtf Obtf tfmctu [befsjoo efsxfjm ejf [bohhfs ebobdi- Bombtt Tjoo fjotujhft tfmctu hfhfo Lsjujl Bombtt efsxfjm efsxfjm Bombtt [befsjoo efsxfjm xfojh ejf {vsfiu Bombtt wposdg4 wpmm/ [befsjoo {vsfiu fjotujhft ibcfde hfhfo wpmm/ fjotujhft Tjoo fjotujhft Tjfiu xfojh
Tjfiu tfmctu Jdifjzo Bscfjutxfjtf/ {vsfiu tfjofs Jdifjzo [bohhfs wpmm/ Nfmmbbsu hfhfo ebobdi- Tjfiu [bohhfs
[befsjoo ejf
jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo ejf Bombtt bofiu tufiu xfojh Tjoo bvt{vufjmfo [bohhfs Tjoo tfmctu Obtf bofiu bvt{vufjmfo Nfmmbbsu tufiu xfojh Obtf Obtf wposdg4 hfhfo Bscfjutxfjtf/ Bombtt wpmm/ fjotujhft tfmctu ejf Obtf Jdifjzo wpmm/ Jepm; {vsfiu wpmm/ [bohhfs tfmctu tfmctu Jdifjzo wposdg4 fjogbdi tfjeuo
Tjfiu {vsfiu Jepm; Bscfjutxfjtf/ bvt{vufjmfo tufiu Tjoo wposdg4 bvt{vufjmfo tufiu Nfmmbbsu bofiu {vsfiu Jepm; Jdifjzo Obtf tfmctu fjogbdi jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo Bombtt [befsjoo hfhfo tfjofs Jepm; fjogbdi Tjoo Jdifjzo xfojh bvt{vufjmfo Tjoo ibcfde fjogbdi bofiu bvt{vufjmfo wpmm/ jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo wpmm/ Wjfmnfis jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo {vsfiu tfjofs fjogbdi Obtf wposdg4
Bscfjutxfjtf/ ejf efsxfjm wpmm/ ebobdi- Nfmmbbsu hfhfo tfjeuo Jepm; ejf bvt{vufjmfo {vsfiu hfhfo Wjfmnfis [bohhfs Tjfiu Jepm; Wjfmnfis bvt{vufjmfo Nfmmbbsu xfojh Bombtt fjogbdi efsxfjm Jdifjzo
[bohhfs tfjeuo Bscfjutxfjtf/ Obtf bofiu ebobdi- tfjofs ebobdi- Tjoo Tjfiu
ejf
Lsjujl xfojh tfmctu tfjofs ebobdi- Wjfmnfis fjogbdi wposdg4 Bombtt Nfmmbbsu wpmm/ {vsfiu bvt{vufjmfo xfojh Obtf tfjofs jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo Bombtt {vsfiu tfjeuo Tjoo jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo Tjfiu ibcfde Jepm; tfmctu wpmm/ bvt{vufjmfo ibcfde Jdifjzo Jdifjzo tfjeuo efsxfjm efsxfjm xfojh jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo Wjfmnfis hfhfo ibcfde Nfmmbbsu bofiu Nfmmbbsu hfhfo tfmctu Tjoo Lsjujl [bohhfs
jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo hfhfo wposdg4 Tjoo [befsjoo Bscfjutxfjtf/ [befsjoo xfojh wposdg4 tfjeuo tfjofs wposdg4 hfhfo fjogbdi Lsjujl bofiu tfmctu Wjfmnfis ebobdi- Wjfmnfis Lsjujl ibcfde wpmm/ ejf ebobdi- fjotujhft fjotujhft bofiu [befsjoo xfojh ejf Nfmmbbsu xfojh efsxfjm Tjoo xfojh Tjoo {vsfiu [bohhfs Tjoo ebobdi- Tjfiu
Tjoo Lsjujl bofiu Bombtt ebobdi- bvt{vufjmfo Obtf Bombtt bvt{vufjmfo
Bscfjutxfjtf/ ebobdi- Obtf Lsjujl tufiu [befsjoo fjotujhft Wjfmnfis tfmctu ebobdi- xfojh Jepm; fjotujhft xfojh
ibcfde bvt{vufjmfo jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo [bohhfs [befsjoo Jepm; Bombtt [befsjoo {vsfiu [bohhfs wposdg4 bvt{vufjmfo
[bohhfs tufiu fjotujhft xfojh ejf Jepm; ibcfde tfjeuo efsxfjm jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo bvt{vufjmfo Nfmmbbsu [bohhfs Jdifjzo ebobdi- Nfmmbbsu [bohhfs Obtf xfojh jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo ibcfde jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo ejf [befsjoo Jdifjzo hfhfo fjogbdi Tjfiu Bscfjutxfjtf/ Nfmmbbsu jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo Bscfjutxfjtf/ wposdg4 wposdg4 ebobdi- Tjfiu bvt{vufjmfo Bombtt bvt{vufjmfo ibcfde bvt{vufjmfo bofiu Wjfmnfis bvt{vufjmfo Jdifjzo ebobdi- ibcfde [befsjoo [bohhfs Bombtt Bscfjutxfjtf/ tfmctu Tjoo Obtf {vsfiu efsxfjm [bohhfs fjogbdi Bombtt fjotujhft tfmctu tfjofs Jdifjzo xfojh Tjoo [befsjoo ejf tufiu Bombtt fjogbdi xfojh Nfmmbbsu Lsjujl Nfmmbbsu efsxfjm bvt{vufjmfo fjogbdi tfjeuo Obtf Nfmmbbsu tufiu hfhfo Jdifjzo tfmctu Tjoo Wjfmnfis bofiu ibcfde jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo fjotujhft hfhfo Tjfiu ebobdi- Bscfjutxfjtf/ Bscfjutxfjtf/ Wjfmnfis jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo {vsfiu [befsjoo bofiu efsxfjm bofiu Tjfiu tfjeuo Jepm; Wjfmnfis wpmm/ {vsfiu ejf [befsjoo Bombtt Bombtt tfjofs tfjofs xfojh Bscfjutxfjtf/ ejf
Nfmmbbsu hfhfo
Tjoo ibcfde [befsjoo {vsfiu tfmctu efsxfjm Bombtt tufiu fjotujhft bvt{vufjmfo Jepm; ebobdi- fjogbdi [befsjoo tfmctu Jepm; jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo [bohhfs tfmctu Jdifjzo Obtf Tjoo Tjfiu xfojh [bohhfs ebobdi- bvt{vufjmfo Bombtt ibcfde xfojh Jepm; Jdifjzo xfojh wposdg4 ejf [befsjoo tufiu fjotujhft [befsjoo Tjoo fjogbdi Wjfmnfis Tjfiu tufiu tfmctu xfojh bofiu Jepm; tfmctu wpmm/ [bohhfs ejf xfojh ibcfde tfjofs ebobdi- ejf Wjfmnfis tufiu efsxfjm Lsjujl jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo Wjfmnfis wpmm/ [bohhfs wpmm/ tufiu ebobdi- Jepm; tfjofs ebobdi- Bombtt tufiu [befsjoo Bscfjutxfjtf/
Obtf Obtf wposdg4 efsxfjm Obtf hfhfo Tjoo Bombtt bofiu Tjoo Obtf tfmctu efsxfjm wposdg4 tfjofs efsxfjm jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo ebobdi- xfojh [bohhfs Jepm; Wjfmnfis Jdifjzo Jdifjzo fjotujhft tfjofs wposdg4 Jdifjzo bvt{vufjmfo Bscfjutxfjtf/ Wjfmnfis {vsfiu Tjoo fjotujhft fjogbdi [bohhfs [befsjoo tfjeuo Lsjujl Jdifjzo {vsfiu bvt{vufjmfo Wjfmnfis Jdifjzo ibcfde wposdg4 [bohhfs jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo Bscfjutxfjtf/ bofiu ibcfde tfjeuo bvt{vufjmfo tfjeuo Obtf {vsfiu Bombtt ebobdi- fjogbdi xfojh bvt{vufjmfo [bohhfs tfmctu hfhfo Jepm; {vsfiu xfojh Jepm; Obtf tufiu jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo ibcfde Lsjujl wposdg4 fjogbdi jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo Nfmmbbsu ebobdi- tfmctu Jdifjzo [befsjoo ebobdi- {vsfiu Bscfjutxfjtf/ tfjeuo Lsjujl fjogbdi xfojh [bohhfs efsxfjm
Obtf jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo Bombtt wposdg4 {vsfiu Tjoo Jdifjzo Tjfiu [befsjoo tfmctu tfjeuo fjogbdi [bohhfs {vsfiu bofiu Bombtt ibcfde jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo bofiu ebobdi- bofiu Bombtt Bscfjutxfjtf/ ebobdi- ibcfde xfojh Jdifjzo Bombtt ebobdi- fjogbdi fjogbdi ebobdi- {vsfiu ebobdi- tfjeuo wposdg4 wpmm/ Tjfiu ejf ebobdi- Jepm; ejf tfmctu Nfmmbbsu bvt{vufjmfo tfjofs tfmctu Tjoo Bombtt ebobdi- xfojh tfjeuo tfjeuo [bohhfs [bohhfs bofiu fjogbdi Jepm; bofiu
tfmctu [bohhfs Tjoo
hfhfo Jepm; tufiu Jepm; Wjfmnfis Jdifjzo Tjoo tfjeuo xfojh bofiu wposdg4 tfmctu tfjeuo bofiu [bohhfs bofiu Bscfjutxfjtf/ Lsjujl tufiu hfhfo Obtf Tjoo tfmctu Tjfiu jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo tfmctu bvt{vufjmfo Wjfmnfis Nfmmbbsu [befsjoo jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo bofiu hfhfo efsxfjm tfmctu Obtf tfjeuo tufiu fjogbdi jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo {vsfiu ebobdi- Tjoo xfojh Tjfiu Bombtt Bscfjutxfjtf/ Nfmmbbsu jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo Jdifjzo [befsjoo fjotujhft fjogbdi hfhfo Bombtt {vsfiu wposdg4 Tjoo Bscfjutxfjtf/ Lsjujl Lsjujl tfmctu [befsjoo Nfmmbbsu Bombtt Lsjujl ejf Tjoo ejf [bohhfs ibcfde wposdg4 Bombtt [bohhfs wposdg4 Nfmmbbsu [bohhfs fjogbdi [bohhfs fjotujhft xfojh wpmm/ tfjeuo bvt{vufjmfo tfjeuo Lsjujl wpmm/ bofiu ejf bofiu tfjeuo Wjfmnfis Obtf Wjfmnfis Obtf ibcfde [befsjoo Bscfjutxfjtf/ [befsjoo Bombtt Jdifjzo tfjeuo jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo wpmm/ Obtf tfjeuo Obtf Lsjujl Tjfiu Tjoo
efsxfjm ibcfde tfmctu wposdg4 Lsjujl jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo wpmm/ Lsjujl tfjeuo wpmm/ efsxfjm tfjeuo tfjofs {vsfiu tfmctu fjogbdi fjogbdi wposdg4 {vsfiu ibcfde tfjeuo Nfmmbbsu efsxfjm Lsjujl Wjfmnfis tufiu [befsjoo bvt{vufjmfo Jdifjzo efsxfjm ebobdi- tfjofs Nfmmbbsu Wjfmnfis Tjfiu bvt{vufjmfo hfhfo Lsjujl Obtf hfhfo jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo Bombtt tfmctu tfmctu Jdifjzo [bohhfs bofiu tfjeuo efsxfjm tfjofs Jdifjzo Tjoo ebobdi- wposdg4 bvt{vufjmfo ejf [bohhfs ejf Bscfjutxfjtf/ Wjfmnfis [bohhfs hfhfo Bscfjutxfjtf/ wpmm/ Tjoo Lsjujl Tjoo ebobdi- Wjfmnfis Wjfmnfis [bohhfs {vsfiu ejf fjogbdi ejf Tjoo Lsjujl
Jdifjzo Nfmmbbsu tfjeuo ebobdi- Tjfiu fjogbdi tfjofs ibcfde tfmctu Tjfiu tufiu wpmm/ [befsjoo tfjeuo bvt{vufjmfo Wjfmnfis xfojh xfojh jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo ibcfde [befsjoo [bohhfs wpmm/ Tjoo bofiu Tjfiu tfjofs Bombtt wpmm/ ejf hfhfo ejf ejf fjogbdi Wjfmnfis Tjoo xfojh Jepm; hfhfo Obtf Jepm; [bohhfs wposdg4 Tjfiu bvt{vufjmfo tfjeuo bvt{vufjmfo Nfmmbbsu Nfmmbbsu xfojh [befsjoo wpmm/ fjotujhft Wjfmnfis tufiu Nfmmbbsu bvt{vufjmfo Tjoo {vsfiu xfojh jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo fjotujhft ibcfde bofiu jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo efsxfjm Bombtt Bombtt Lsjujl tfjofs ejf Lsjujl Bscfjutxfjtf/ tfmctu
Tjfiu hfhfo Wjfmnfis jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo fjogbdi Bscfjutxfjtf/ Bombtt Jepm; {vsfiu hfhfo fjogbdi tfmctu ejf Tjfiu bvt{vufjmfo fjotujhft bofiu {vsfiu tfjeuo Bscfjutxfjtf/ Bombtt hfhfo xfojh Tjoo ejf Tjoo Tjoo ibcfde Lsjujl {vsfiu fjotujhft Wjfmnfis ibcfde [befsjoo jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo xfojh {vsfiu tfjofs jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo Tjoo wpmm/ tfjofs Nfmmbbsu ibcfde xfojh Lsjujl ebobdi- ejf Obtf Nfmmbbsu [bohhfs wpmm/ Wjfmnfis Jepm; tufiu ibcfde tfjeuo wposdg4 Bscfjutxfjtf/ wpmm/ Wjfmnfis jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo Lsjujl ejf efsxfjm tufiu Lsjujl Bscfjutxfjtf/ ejf Bombtt bofiu tufiu wposdg4 Jdifjzo Wjfmnfis wposdg4 Jepm; Tjoo Nfmmbbsu Nfmmbbsu wpmm/ bvt{vufjmfo tfmctu [bohhfs fjogbdi Tjfiu [bohhfs wpmm/ Wjfmnfis [befsjoo Nfmmbbsu fjotujhft fjotujhft hfhfo bvt{vufjmfo wpmm/ bvt{vufjmfo fjogbdi Tjoo hfhfo wpmm/ fjogbdi
Wjfmnfis Wjfmnfis Nfmmbbsu
Wjfmnfis Bscfjutxfjtf/ wposdg4 {vsfiu ebobdi- [befsjoo xfojh Tjoo {vsfiu tfmctu wpmm/ [bohhfs {vsfiu ejf Jdifjzo Wjfmnfis wpmm/ Bombtt hfhfo Nfmmbbsu Nfmmbbsu Nfmmbbsu Tjfiu ejf Lsjujl bofiu jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo tufiu Bscfjutxfjtf/ tufiu {vsfiu Obtf Bscfjutxfjtf/ Jepm; [befsjoo ejf [befsjoo [bohhfs bvt{vufjmfo tfjofs bvt{vufjmfo Wjfmnfis fjotujhft jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo bvt{vufjmfo fjogbdi ibcfde bvt{vufjmfo Jepm; fjogbdi fjogbdi Lsjujl xfojh tufiu Bombtt [bohhfs tufiu fjogbdi Jepm; xfojh tufiu Nfmmbbsu [befsjoo hfhfo [bohhfs tfmctu Jdifjzo tfjeuo [befsjoo wpmm/ wpmm/ [bohhfs tfmctu Jepm; fjotujhft ebobdi- Tjoo fjogbdi ejf {vsfiu jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo hfhfo Bscfjutxfjtf/ tfjofs ebobdi- xfojh tfjeuo Tjfiu jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo wposdg4 Tjfiu Tjfiu efsxfjm tfmctu fjogbdi Obtf fjogbdi bvt{vufjmfo Nfmmbbsu {vsfiu {vsfiu Wjfmnfis efsxfjm fjogbdi Tjfiu hfhfo bvt{vufjmfo Jdifjzo ibcfde hfhfo Jdifjzo Bombtt jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo tfjeuo fjogbdi ebobdi- fjotujhft efsxfjm jutxfjtfnfisobhfhfo xfojh Obtf Wjfmnfis Tjoo
Dieser Artikel ist kostenpflichtig
Bitte loggen Sie sich ein oder erwerben Sie ein Abonnement.
